Review of The Prisoner
The Prisoner is such a sad waste of potential. The hook is great: A British secret agent resigns in a fury. While packing to travel abroad, he is attacked with sleeping gas; he wakes up in a seemingly charming village where everyone has numbers instead of names, and the authorities are deadly interested in why he resigned.
The most frustrating part is that a better version of the show existed on paper. The original idea that Patrick McGoohan and George Markstein came up with while working on Danger Man was so much better:
Years earlier, the agent had proposed a humane way to retire spies who still knew too much. After discovering his idea has been implemented, not as a retirement home but as an interrogation center and prison, he is outraged and resigns. He knows that resigning will get him sent there, but his plan is to learn how the place works and destroy it. And because the Village is full of agents of every nationality, he can't even be sure whose Village it is: his own side's, or the enemy's.
Now that is a story. It gives the hero a reason to resign, a reason to be in the Village, a goal, and a personal stake: he is a prisoner of his own invention. It even has a basis in reality: Inverlair Lodge, a remote Scottish house where Britain held people who knew too much during the Second World War.
Markstein left production of The Prisoner after the thirteenth episode was filmed. I expect he had realized by that point that there was no way they were going to deliver any kind of coherent story.
All Questions and No Answers
The show's creators had no idea what to do with any of their core themes and elements. Is the Village a functioning society in any way, or just a parody of one? Are the other residents prisoners in the same predicament as Number Six, or are they all working against him? Can any of them be trusted? Who is Number One, and why is there a new Number Two in almost every episode?
The show gestures vaguely at these questions and does nothing with them. Few meaningful facts are revealed across the whole series, and when we do get concrete information about the Village in one of the best episodes, that information has no bearing whatsoever on later episodes.
Number Two is the clearest example. The constant rotation of the Village's administrator could be the underpinning of the plot all by itself, cashing out in our seeing power struggles, glimpses of how the Village punishes failure, and a ladder of authority that Number Six might climb (or, more likely, kick down.) We can guess that the constant turnover of Number Twos is a tactic to keep Number Six off balance, but guesses are all the viewer has. Two actors play Number Two more than once. Is that significant? Not only does the show never tell us, I guarantee you the writers had no idea.
The show is an absurd patchwork of half-baked stories that mean nothing.
Theme Without Substance
Once you get the gist of the show, watching each new episode is an exercise in suspending your disbelief and not caring what happens. If each episode at least revealed a little more about who Number Six is, and why his resignation matters so much to the people running the Village, that would be something, but the writers don't even manage that.
Worse, most episodes have effectively the same structure: Number Two tries a coercion technique, Number Six resists, the technique fails, and nothing changes.
There's precious little meaningful difference between "Living in Harmony," where Number Six is drugged into believing he's a sheriff trapped in the Old West, and "A. B. and C.," where Number Two drugs him and directs his dreams.
Everything resets between episodes. In "Free for All," Number Six runs for election as Number Two and wins. That could have turned into so much more. It changes nothing. In "The Girl Who Was Death," the final moments reveal that the episode, a spy caper (itself a nice change of pace, I'll grant), was a bedtime story that Number Six has been telling the Village children. What was the point of the episode?
Even the central question — why did Number Six resign? — isn't handled consistently. Somewhere between halfway and two-thirds of the way through, the resignation simply stops coming up, only to return in the final episodes as if it had been the point the whole time.
Rover, the "breathing" white balloon that guards the Village, is a plot device I can overlook. It's silly, but it has a discernible function: it stops people leaving. The trouble is that it doesn't obey any kind of logic. It turns up when the plot needs it and stays away when the plot doesn't. Then again, the show doesn't obey any other logic either.
There are half a dozen proposed viewing orders for the show. The production order and the original UK broadcast order differ; the American broadcast order differs from those, and in turn differs from the order used by an A&E collected edition. I believe McGoohan intended yet another order. Fans agree on the first episode coming first and the last two coming last, and that's all.
None of that matters. I defy you to find any order that makes the whole series make sense. I can’t even be bothered to go look at my hard drive and see what order I watched them in, although I think it was A&E.
Two Glimpses of a Better Show
For my money, the best episode by far is "The Chimes of Big Ben." A new prisoner, Nadia, arrives, and she and Number Six plan an escape together. It works: they are smuggled out in a crate, all the way to his old superiors' office in London.
Everything seems to be going so well, but just as Number Six is about to explain why he resigned, Big Ben strikes the hour. The time matches the watch he picked up in Poland, but it should have been an hour ahead. Growing suspicious, Number Six opens a door… and walks out into the Village, where Nadia is standing beside Number Two.
A close runner-up is "Many Happy Returns." Number Six wakes to find the Village deserted, builds a raft, and after weeks at sea makes his way back to London. We can feel his desperation and isolation in those weeks on the raft. In London, Number Six meets people he used to know in the intelligence service and convinces them the Village is real. He arranges to be sent up in a plane to find it, and he spots it from the air… but the pilot has been swapped for a Village agent, who ejects him.
These are the only two episodes where the stakes feel real. Number Six actually leaves! We learn that the outside world still exists, and that the Village's reach extends into the British intelligence service! Yet ultimately these episodes affect the plot no more or less than the awful fever-dream episode in which Number Six is regressed to a childlike state and locked up with a Number Two.
It's probably no coincidence that those episodes feel closest to the grounded spy story Markstein and McGoohan originally had in mind. A better show would have used one or both of these as the turning point, after which Number Six converts his blind rage at being imprisoned into a calculating and cunning drive to revenge himself upon his captors.
Redemption
What I would love to do is take the entire run of The Prisoner, cut it into individual shots a few seconds long, catalogue them, and stitch them back together — with as little video or audio editing as possible — into a short film which addresses the same themes but has a real plot and a proper resolution.
All the raw material is there: McGoohan pacing like a caged tiger or contorting his face in rage; interrogations with a parade of Number Twos; escapes, recaptures, London. The original plan for a spy imprisoned inside his own idea is itself imprisoned within this show. It could be broken free.
I originally thought that if I made the film, I'd call it Number Six, but on reflection, there's only one possible title: Be Seeing You.